From: Ben Goertzel (email@example.com)
Date: Mon Apr 01 2002 - 20:19:14 MST
> As I understand it, the core people working on Novamente are people who
> worked together for an extended period on Webmind and hence are already
> trained to work together on the task at hand.
> With that core group of
> full-time experienced people, it becomes possible to coordinate
> although I don't know if you have any non-Webmind volunteers at this
None who are working yet. I have a number of new recruits, mainly from this
list, and I'll tell you in 6 months how things worked out in this regard ;)
> Would you have wanted to *start out* work on Webmind with a few
> volunteers? Do you think it would have gotten anywhere?
I *did* start out with a few volunteers, in 1997-early 1998 before achieving
funding for Webmind Inc. Those volunteers became the cofounders of Webmind
> Maybe it would,
> since Webmind had a much-less-tight architecture (I expect), but would it
> have worked for starting out on building Novamente if you hadn't already
> built Webmind?
Actually, I think the key to using a widely-distributed team is having a
VERY tight & complete design. Implementation of a complete design in a
distributed fashion is a lot easier than the process of converging from
ambiguous brainstormy ideas to definite designs.
> Starting on real AI takes programmers working together in the
> same physical
> location, full time,
I am not so sure that this is true. It MAY be true, but I can't imagine how
you can be *so definite* about such a thing, given your limited experience
base in software project management.
In my experience, F2F contact is valuable but intermittent F2F may be
adequate, coupled with frequent e-mail and/or chat contact.
My point is that we cannot wait for ideal conditions to begin implementing
Real AI's. Yes, it would be nice to have ample funding, and isolate 1000
researchers/programmers on 50 islands with 20 per island, each pursuing a
potentially different approach. But this is not what Mr. Gates has decided
to do with his spare change this week. I am committed to pursuing
team-based Singularity-focused Real AI development by whatever means are
Having said that -- of course, if having a team in the same location as you,
all focused full-time on the project, is the *only* approach that makes you
adequately comfortable to proceed ... well then, maybe this has to be the
way for you to proceed. Best of luck!
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Wed Jul 17 2013 - 04:00:37 MDT