Early IQ Repost

From: Tennessee Leeuwenburg (tennessee@tennessee.id.au)
Date: Mon Nov 21 2005 - 06:34:04 MST

I never actually got a direct response to my first post in this thread,
and the discussion has deviated well outside my line of thinking. That's
fine, but I still have my original train of thought waiting at the
station, so to speak. Original post follows:

Eliezer, what is your (self-estimated) IQ?

I am not familiar with the GPA, but I assume it's strongly correlated,
and you said it like your scores were good.

I am not a genius, but I am clever. (IQ 130ish, 98th percentile, which
makes me uncommon but not rare).

I know people who are cleverer by a further order of magnitude (member
of 999 club), but I still find I have more in common with them than
people relatively close in the downwards direction. Obviously, that's my
perception, not theirs, but so it is.

The supposition I have is that IQ is largely unrelated to passion or
motivation, especially moving towards adulthood where the natural
curiosity and drive of childhood wears off. The most successful people
(according to society's usual metrics) are not the most intelligent, but
the most obsessed, with IQ being a secondary correlate.

It's probably not right to see the reduction in motivation of a child
prodigy as a failure. In fact, it's probably not fair to push our own
beliefs about success onto others (argument from paternalism). However,
it is wonderful when someone of high intellect pursues the goals which I
find important.


This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Wed Jul 17 2013 - 04:00:53 MDT