From: 1Arcturus (arcturus12453@yahoo.com)
Date: Wed Dec 14 2005 - 09:45:51 MST
Jef Allbright <jef@jefallbright.net> wrote: (1) Can we agree that increasing knowledge (of the
objective/scientific/instrumental kind) tends to increase the
capability of any agent to achieve its (subjective) goals, therefore
increasing objective knowledge of how things work is necessarilly good
(from the point of view of any subjective agent?)
Obvious answer? No, since, say, solving a great scientific problem about ant migratory patterns isn't going to stop one from being killed in a car accident, which may end all one's goal-oriented behaviors. I think Nature classifies this under Smart Vs. Clever Vs. Lucky. :)
gej
This is similar to the popular question "Is scientific progress
inherently good?", but the significant difference here is I am
carefully specifying the question (for the moment) in terms of
individual, subjective good, since, as we agreed earlier, "good" in
itself is meaningless.
- Jef
On 12/14/05, Peter Voss
wrote:
> People use 'good' and 'bad' in fundamentally different ways - to mean:
>
> a) Good in itself (an invalid concept as far as I'm concerned - 'good' is
> basically an adjective, not noun)
> b) good to achieve a specified goal, seen as desirable by a specified
> entity.
>
> See 'Good and Bad' in http://www.optimal.org/peter/rational_ethics.htm
>
> This also covers 'what morality is about'.
>
> From: owner-sl4@sl4.org [mailto:owner-sl4@sl4.org]On Behalf Of Jef Allbright
> ....
>
> The key question I was trying to put forth in this discussion is
> whether we could all agree that for any agent, that which promotes the
> agent's goals would necessarily be seen as good from the point of view
> of that agent. I think this is an important first step to
> understanding what "morality" is really about, and it's amazing to me
> how difficult it is to get anyone to address this and subsequent
> questions in this line of thought in (what seems to me) a simple and
> logical manner.
---------------------------------
Yahoo! Shopping
Find Great Deals on Holiday Gifts at Yahoo! Shopping
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.5 : Wed Jul 17 2013 - 04:00:54 MDT